Legal Definitions

Sewage Spill Showdown: Cedar Lodge’s Fight for Justice Against Fairway View Apartments

Published on: September 25, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-quang-nguyen-vinh-222549-2172499-scaled A picturesque pond, once teeming with life, transformed into a murky, foul-smelling mess. The culprit? Alleged sewage contamination from a neighboring apartment complex. This is the story of Cedar Lodge Plantation’s battle against Fairway View Apartments in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, a legal fight that highlights the complexities of environmental disputes and property damage claims.

The Contamination Crisis:

In 2012, Cedar Lodge discovered their pond had been contaminated with sewage, evidenced by high levels of fecal coliform bacteria. The source was traced back to the adjacent Fairway View Apartments. Cedar Lodge’s plans to develop their property into a residential and commercial community were shattered, leading them to sue the apartment owners and their sewage treatment contractor.

Underwater Collision Sparks Legal Battle: Shell Offshore vs. Tesla and International

Published on: September 24, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-lastly-590178-scaled In the depths of the Gulf of Mexico, a seemingly minor incident set off a chain of legal events that reverberated through the maritime industry. An underwater sonar device, or towfish, collided with the mooring line of a Shell Offshore drilling rig, causing significant damage. The resulting legal battle involved Shell, the company operating the sonar device (Tesla Offshore), and the vessel’s owner (International Offshore Services). This blog post explores the key issues of the case, the court’s rulings, and the implications for maritime operations.

The Incident:

Tesla Offshore was conducting an archaeological survey of the ocean floor using a towfish pulled by a vessel chartered from International Offshore Services. Despite having prior information about the location of Shell’s drilling rig, Tesla failed to share this with the vessel’s crew. The towfish struck one of the rig’s mooring lines, causing damage and disrupting Shell’s operations.

Safety Recall Doesn’t Negate Redhibition: Louisiana Court Rules in Favor of Car Buyer

Published on: September 23, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-mikebirdy-193999-scaled In a victory for consumer rights, the Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal recently overturned a trial court’s decision to dismiss a redhibition claim against Mercedes-Benz USA (MBUSA). The case, Philip A. Franco v. Mercedes-Benz USA, LLC, involved a defective airbag and highlights the interplay between safety recalls and Louisiana’s redhibition laws.

Case Background

Philip Franco purchased a used 2010 Mercedes-Benz GL450 SUV in 2013. In 2016, he received a safety recall notice from MBUSA regarding a potentially dangerous defect in the driver-side airbag. The defect could cause metal fragments to be propelled toward the driver or passengers in the event of an accident, potentially resulting in severe injury or death. MBUSA’s notice stated that a suitable replacement was not yet available but would be provided free of charge when it was.

When Ignoring Student Debt Comes Back to Bite: Xavier University Wins Key Court Battle

Published on: September 21, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-pixabay-159740-scaled In a recent ruling highlighting the importance of responding to legal actions, the Louisiana Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit, sided with Xavier University of Louisiana in a case involving unpaid student debt. The court reversed a lower court’s decision, granting Xavier University a preliminary default judgment against a former student, Elemuel Coleman.

Xavier University filed a lawsuit in 2015 seeking to recover over $21,000 in student loan debt from Coleman. After initial attempts to serve Coleman through the sheriff’s office failed, the court appointed a private process server. The process server successfully delivered the legal documents to Coleman’s residence, leaving them with a person of suitable age and discretion who also lived there.

Despite being served, Coleman failed to respond to the lawsuit within the required timeframe. Xavier University then filed a motion for a preliminary default judgment, a legal maneuver that can lead to a judgment in favor of the plaintiff if the defendant fails to respond to the lawsuit.

Injured Worker Wins Right to Shoulder Surgery: Court Upholds Decision Against Employer and Insurer

Published on: September 20, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

In a victory for injured workers in Louisiana, the Court of Appeal for the Fourth Circuit recently upheld a decision granting Lorae Burnett the right to shoulder surgery following a work-related motor vehicle accident. The case, Burnett v. Full Force Staffing, LLC, & LUBA Casualty Insurance Company, centered on interpreting the state’s Medical Treatment Guidelines and whether the recommended surgery was medically necessary and appropriate.

Background of the Case:

Mr. Burnett, an employee of Full Force Staffing, was injured in a motor vehicle accident while on the job. He sought workers’ compensation benefits for various injuries, including significant pain in his right shoulder. After receiving conservative treatment that failed to alleviate his pain, Mr. Burnett’s orthopedic shoulder specialist, Dr. Savoie, recommended surgery.

Siblings Awarded $200K in Legal Malpractice Case: A Cautionary Tale of Attorney Negligence

Published on: September 19, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-sora-shimazaki-5669602-1-scaled In a poignant reminder of the potential consequences of attorney negligence, the Louisiana Court of Appeal recently upheld a substantial $200,000 legal malpractice award to four siblings who tragically lost their brother due to their former attorneys’ alleged mishandling of a wrongful death lawsuit. This case highlights the importance of competent legal representation and the potential consequences of attorney negligence.

Case Background

The plaintiffs, siblings of the deceased Frank Anthony Dawson, hired the defendants, Gray & Gray and James Gray, II, to represent them in a wrongful death and survival action against the Sheriff of St. Tammany Parish. Mr. Dawson tragically died by suicide while under suicide watch in the sheriff’s custody.

Louisiana Court Reverses Summary Judgment in Medical Malpractice Case, Highlighting Importance of Fact-Finding in Proving Negligence

Published on: September 17, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-jonathanborba-3279197-1-scaled In a significant development for medical malpractice litigation in Louisiana, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal recently reversed a summary judgment, underscoring the importance of thorough fact-finding and the potential need for expert testimony in such cases. The case, Diana Deruise-Pierce v. University Healthcare System, L.C., et al., underscores the necessity of thorough fact-finding and the potential need for expert testimony in medical malpractice cases, even when negligence appears evident.

Case Overview:

The lawsuit stemmed from the treatment rendered to Mr. Pierce at University Medical Center in New Orleans. Mr. Pierce was admitted for a medical procedure, but his condition deteriorated overnight. Despite this, the medical team proceeded with the planned procedure.

Louisiana Court Grapples with Complexities of Adoption in Wrongful Death Case

Published on: September 16, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-fotios-photos-1909015-scaled A recent ruling by the Louisiana Court of Appeal, Third Circuit, has shed light on the complex interplay between adoption and the right to file wrongful death and survival actions. The consolidated cases, stemming from a tragic car accident that claimed the lives of Richard Stewart, Jr., and his two minor children, raised questions about whether adopted children and biological half-siblings can pursue such claims.

The accident resulted in the deaths of Richard Stewart, Jr., and his two minor children. Mr. Stewart was survived by his wife, Lisa Stewart, and two adult sons, Daniel Goins and David Watts, who were adopted as minors. Additionally, the deceased minor children had a biological mother, Brandi Hardie, who was not a party to the lawsuits.

Following the accident, multiple survival and wrongful death actions were filed. The central issue was whether Goins and Watts, as adopted children and biological half-siblings, had the right to bring these claims.

Louisiana Court Raises the Bar on General Damages in Unprovoked Attack Case

Published on: September 15, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-sora-shimazaki-5668772-1-scaled In a recent decision, the Louisiana Court of Appeal, Third Circuit, affirmed and amended a default judgment in favor of Matthew Hillman, who was injured in an unprovoked attack by Corey Seneca. The court upheld the special damages award but found the general damages award to be abusively low, increasing it from $2,500 to $10,000.

Matthew Hillman filed a lawsuit against Corey Seneca after being attacked without provocation. Mr. Seneca failed to respond to the lawsuit, leading to a default judgment in favor of Mr. Hillman. During the confirmation hearing for the default judgment, Mr. Hillman provided evidence of his injuries, which included a lacerated lip requiring fifteen stitches, fractured teeth, and the inability to eat solid food for two months. He also testified about his pain and suffering and loss of income due to the attack.

The trial court awarded Mr. Hillman special damages of $2,894.19 for lost wages, past medical expenses, and future dental treatment. However, it granted only $2,500 in general damages for pain and suffering. Mr. Hillman appealed the judgment, arguing that the general damages award was insufficient.

Work-Related Knee Injury Leads to Multiple Compensable Injuries: Louisiana Court’s Ruling

Published on: September 9, 2024 | By Berniard Law Firm

pexels-ganajp-18021337-scaled A recent ruling by the Louisiana Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal in Rodney Loar v. LUBA Worker’s Comp Terminix Service Company, Inc. highlights the complex nature of workers’ compensation claims and the challenges in determining which subsequent injuries are compensable.

Rodney Loar, a technician for Terminix, injured his right knee and head in a work-related accident in 2011. He underwent multiple surgeries, including a total knee replacement. Subsequently, he experienced instability in his right knee, leading to falls and injuries to his left knee, left shoulder, right hip, and lower back.

Critical Issues in the Case: